FHN+-+Dandridge+v.+Williams


 * __Read at DCD:__**

**Plan: The federal judiciary of the United States should overturn Dandridge v. Williams on the grounds that family caps on welfare violate a child’s right to welfare under the equal protection clause of the 14****th** **amendment.**

Julie **Nice** , Delaney Professor of Law, University of Denver Sturm College of Law April  **2008**  , "No scrutiny whatsoever: deconstitutionalization of poverty law, dual rules of law, & dialogic default.", Fordham Urban Law Journal, 35.3, 629(43). Over time, these forces of deconstitutionalization... to equal protection under the law.
 * Advantage 1: Constitutional protection**
 * A. The impoverished have been deconstitutionalized. Their freedom of speech to challenge their oppression destroyed and business is allowed to run rampant over them.**

Julie A. **Nice** , Delaney Professor of Law, University of Denver Sturm College of Law April  **2008**  , "No scrutiny whatsoever: deconstitutionalization of poverty law, dual rules of law, & dialogic default.", Fordham Urban Law Journal, 35.3, 629(43). Regardless of some outlier exceptions... vulnerable outside the Constitution's protection. (57)
 * B. Dandridge v. Williams is the cornerstone of this silencing. It must be overturned.**

=C. When free speech is taken away, genocide and war become rampant. Failure to provide free speech also eliminates real democracy.= Frances   **D’Souza**  ,  Executive   Director of Article 19, International Centre Against Censorship,   4-25-  **1996**  “Freedom of Expression: The First Freedom?”, Hearing before the Committee on Foreign Affairs, Security and Defence Policy Subcommittee on Human Rights, European Parliament, http://www.europarl.europa.eu/hearings/19960425/droi/freedom_en.htm In the absence of freedom of expression...to occur could have been prevented.

Nuclear, chemical and biological weapons continue...security and prosperity can be built __.
 * D. Democracy is the internal link to all impacts including nuclear, chemical, and biological warfare, economic collapse, environment, international treaties, terrorism, and poverty **
 * Diamond 95** (Larry, Hoover Institution, Stanford University, December, //Promoting Democracy in the 1990s//, 19**95**, [|http://www.carnegie.org//sub/pubs/deadly/diam_rpt.html] )
 * Advantage 2: Indian Modeling**__

Sandra **Day O’Connor**,  Supreme Court justice,  **and**  Jeffrey  **Toobin**  CNN legal analyst,  **2007**  , ‘The Nine’, pg. 242 There was an ideological component to...unfortu­nately, has not been reciprocal." [|Anupam] [|**Mukerji**], MBA from S.P. Jain Institute of Management & Research, rated one of India’s top ten business schools; CEO of Media Marketing Innovators,  2-7-  **2008** ,  [] Can a country where a third...base in India can feel truly secure.
 * A. Supreme Court rulings on welfare rights like Dandridge v. Williams are modeled and applied in India.**
 * B. Current rich-poor gap in India leads to Indian economic collapse**

Teresita **Schaffer** ,  Director of the South Asia Program at the C  enter for Strategic and International Studies, Spring  **2002**  , ‘Building a New Partnership with India’, The Washington Quarterly Mediocre growth will extract... desperate move by Pakistan.
 * C. Economic Collapse leads to war with Pakistan.**

**The Washington Times**   7-8-  **2001** The most dangerous place on the planet is Kashmir... an impending Fissile Material/Cut-off Convention.
 * D. An Indo-Pak conflict would lead to global nuclear war**

**E. India’s economy is key to the world economy** **Reuters**, 9-21-  **2005**  , [] India's booming but relatively closed economy... world growth over the next decade.

**F. Economic collapse leads to nuclear war and bio-weapons use.** Phil **Kerpen** , Policy Director of Americans for Prosperity, an organization of grassroots leaders who engage citizens in the name of limited government and free markets on the local, state and federal levels, 10-28-  **2008**  , “From Panic to Depression?,” The National Review, http://article.nationalreview.com/?q...JiNWVkMTIxMmU= It’s important that we avoid... risk armed conflicts on an even greater scale.


 * Advantage 3: Eugenics**

A Dandridge v. Williams allows mass devaluing of human lives. Currently there is no constitutional protection against eugenics. Lisa Powell , Juris Doctor Candidate, Yale Law School. 2002, Yale Law & Policy Review ‘Eugenics and Equality: Does the Constitution Allow Policies Designed To Discourage Reproduction Among Disfavored Groups?’ Because the undue burden framework was... is offensive to any notion of equality. B. Eugenic devaluation justifies a laundry list of impacts Katheryn D. Katz , prof. of law - Albany Law School,  1997  , Albany Law Journal

It is undeniable that throughout...justifying indifference to the poverty  and misery  of others.

Solvency: A. Dandridge v. Williams violates the Equal Protection Clause and should be overturned. Supreme Court Justice Thurgood  Marshall , J.D. from Howard University, won 29 of 32 cases argued in front of the Supreme Court when he was a lawyer, 4-6-  1970   [] Having decided that the injunction...have been utilized by this Court.

Julie **Nice** , Delaney Professor of Law, University of Denver Sturm College of Law April  **2008**  , "No scrutiny whatsoever: deconstitutionalization of poverty law, dual rules of law, & dialogic default.", Fordham Urban Law Journal, 35.3, 629(43). While McCann does not assume ... both the haves and the have-nots.
 * B. Overruling Dandridge v. Williams grants the impoverished constitutional rights that spill over to movements for the rights of the poor and inclusion within society.**

C. Welfare has been lost in India, plan is key to provide them social and economic leverage. John Samuel,  Executive Director of the Research and Documentation Unit, National Centre for Advocacy Studies,  and Dr.  Gnana  Prakasam  Team Leader of the Research and Documentation Unit, National Centre for Advocacy Studies,  2001 Social watch 2001 report on India After a decade...is still a dream for most Indians.